Eggnog (Low-Carb, Keto)

There are a few seasonal drinks that clearly and distinctly let you know what time of year it is: lemonade, piña coladas, sorrel drink, pumpkin spice lattes, and of course: eggnog.

Eggnog is a holiday staple in the US and for good reason – it’s delicious. Unfortunately, it’s not exactly low-carb and the stuff you buy at the store is filled to the brim with fillers. So much so that the ‘FDA regulations (as of January 2015) require eggnog to contain at least 1% egg yolk solids and at least 8.25% milk solids’ (wiki). Which, we all know that the commercial producers are not going to add more than those minimum requirements – it’s just business.

But, we can easily make our own and make it low-carb and keto-friendly! And it’s actually incredibly easy. The interesting part is that eggnog is basically the beginning steps of both creme brulee as well as icecream, except we don’t have to worry about the complicated aspects of those recipes (i.e. water baths or churning). By knowing how to make eggnog, it also means we can have it year round because eggnog is delicious and works incredibly well as a fat bomb. Its also composed of off-the-shelf ingredients, which is also makes it a breeze to souce.

There are a couple versions of eggnog – one of which uses raw eggs and the egg whites and another that cooks the yolks and omits the egg whites. In the video I go into both, but I prefer the cooked eggnog as it’s creamier and much close to what you would buy in the store.

Can I omit the whole milk?

Yes, you can omit the whole milk! The reason I recommend using lactose free whole milk is for three reasons:

  1. Lactose free milk typically has less carbs and will work for lactose intolerant folks.
  2. Using two cups of heavy cream makes the eggnog taste and feel overly fatty to me, which is something I didn’t want.
  3. Using two cups of unsweet almond milk, give the nog too much of that almond milk taste.

If you choose to omit the milk, simply split the difference and use 1.5 cups heavy cream and 1.5 cups of almond milk. That middle ground works decently well. You can also substitute with a bit of heavy cream and some water since milk is essentially watered down cream (not exactly, but essentially).

Eggnog - Black Tie Kitchen
The beautiful eggnog, up close! – Black Tie Kitchen

What alcohol is in eggnog?

The alcohol in eggnog can be used to taste of the drinker. Traditionally in the US, it was made with rum. After the blockades and such, they changed to using an alcohol that was available, thus whiskey. You could also use brandy or even vodka, but avoid any alcohol that is floral (e.g. gin), overly peaty (some whiskeys), and overproof. If you’re an experienced alcohol enthusiast, then I’d recommend the overproof liquors, otherwise, it will be overpowering for most.

My preference for eggnog is actually a mix of both whiskey and dark rum. It sounds crazy, but the subtle flavor of each liquor really compliment the eggnog and give it a fantastic overall complexity that’s delicious.

What does eggnog taste like?

If you’ve never had eggnog, don’t worry, it doesn’t taste like eggs. Think of it as a liquid creme brulee – creamy, not overly milky (oddly), sweet, and a the spices!

Eggs in a Bowl - Black Tie Kitchen
Look at these beautiful egg yolks! They’re one of the key ingredients!

Does eggnog require raw eggs?

The knock down, old school classic eggnog version DOES require raw eggs. However, there are ways around this:

  1. Make this version of the recipe which uses cooks the egg yolks
  2. Use pasteurized eggs
  3. Add alcohol and let sit for a 1-2 days.

Yes, you read that right – add alcohol. There have been a few studies that show the ability of alcohol to kill E. Coli and Salmonella – and typically within 24-48 hours the task can be accomplished (link). Simply dump your liquor preference in, and place it into the fridge. You can actually even age eggnog (I’m in the midst of this experiment!).

Is this eggnog keto friendly?

For sure – especially if you omit the alcohol! It’s literally a fat-bomb. I found myself at the end of the day being short on my fat intake and would simply consume a couple of ounces of the liquid gold. It’s one hell of a way to get your fat intake.

Why so many spices in your recipe?

I simply enjoy the flavor combination. I have nothing against the nutmeg only eggnogs, but I don’t find it as complex, appetizing, and appealing. Hate me for it, I like flavor :shrug:

Looking for something slightly different?

How about a Rumchata or a staple of the Caribbean (e.g. the eggnog of the Caribbean), Coquito?

Eggnog - Black Tie Kitchen

Eggnog, Low-Carb & Keto

Yield: 6 servings
Prep Time: 5 minutes
Cook Time: 10 minutes
Additional Time: 30 minutes
Total Time: 45 minutes

A classic holiday drink, it can be made boozy, or consumed straight!

Ingredients

  • 5 large eggs
  • 1 cup heavy cream
  • 1 cup unsweetened almond milk
  • 1 cup lactose free whole milk (or you can use another cup of heavy cream or almond milk if you wish)
  • 1 cup + 2 tsp allulose
  • 3 tsp vanilla extract
  • 2 tsp ground nutmeg
  • 1 cinnamon stick
  • ½ cup whiskey (optional)
  • ½ cup dark rum (optional)

Hardware

Instructions

  1. In a large bowl, separate the egg whites from the yolks. Do as you wish with the whites - we want the yolks.
  2. Add half a cup of allulose into the eggs and whisk until the sweetener is completely dissolved. If you're using erythitrol, it will not completely dissolve, so whisk until *mostly* dissolved.
  3. Add another half cup of allulose to the yolks and whisk until dissolved.
  4. In a medium pot, add the heavy cream, almond milk, whole milk, cinnamon stick, nutmeg, and vanilla extract. Heat the mixture just until it starts to boil then remove from the heat.
  5. Temper the eggs with the milk mixture. Using a ladle, slowly pour the hot milk into the eggs while feverishly whisking. We want to bring the egg yolks up to temperature by slowly adding the hot liquid. Do this for 3-4 ladle fulls.
  6. Pour the egg yolk mixture back into the pot and bring the pot to at a temperature of 160°F/71°C.
  7. Remove the mixture from the heat and pour through a sieve into a quart container.
  8. You can add the alcohol now or keep it without alcohol.
  9. Place in refrigerator to cool (ideally, overnight).
  10. Serve cool or warm, and enjoy!

Notes

- This cooked version yields a very creamy nog that's safe to consume as it doesn't have raw eggs.

- The carb count can be lowered if you decide not to use the whole milk

- You can substitute 0.5 cups almond milk and 0.5 cups heavy cream in place of the 1 cup milk

Recommended Products

As an Amazon Associate and member of other affiliate programs, I earn from qualifying purchases at NO cost to you! This helps keep the lights on, the site running, and the videos coming!

Nutrition Information
Serving Size 4 ounces
Amount Per Serving Calories 211Total Fat 18.8gCarbohydrates 4.7gNet Carbohydrates 4.5gFiber 0.2gProtein 4.6g

Enjoy this eggnog over the holidays?

Tag @blacktiekitchen so I can see how it turned out!

Eggnog (Low-Carb, Keto)
Eggnog - Black Tie Kitchen

Leave a Reply